My Sweet Lilly

Erica Zlatovich 2 months ago

I don’t know if we just visited on a really bad day but our treats were horrible. We are pretty big sweet fanatics, love any and all sweets. My husband especially likes things to be a little less sweet than I do but we truly aren’t picky. We ordered macarons, buckeyes and cannolis. Tried the macrons first, they were okay but not true macrons. They fell apart, very hallow and just not good. Glad we only got one each. Then we tried the buckeyes and they were horrible. The peanut butter was SO dry, I felt like I was eating a KFC biscuit. The chocolate had no flavor. I didn’t even want to finish it after the first bite but I drank a lot of water with it. Then the cannolis, typically our favorite things! These were actually disgusting and I could not even finish mine. My husband didn’t want to finish him. I think the filling must have been straight up ricotta, it was chunky and not sweet and also dry. There was very little taste, maybe even stale. We spent $25 and the stuff we ate was horrible and the rest will go in the garbage. Soooo disappointing!

Jftravels 8 months ago

My Sweet Lilly is a boutique bakery located in the heart of Pittsburgh's Strip District. It is uniquely known for catering to both people and their pets, offering a mix of traditional European-style pastries and gourmet dog treats. The shop has a charming, local feel with an artful display of colorful sweets that makes it a popular stop for those exploring the neighborhood. I highly recommend stopping here! The cannolis are delicious!

Dorie Smith 9 months ago

We stopped in to get some snacks for our doggo friends and ended up with treats for puppy and hoomans! Pistachio biscotti, Chocolate biscotti, Lady Locks, rolled pizzelle and a cannoli. The Lady Locks were light, airy and the cream was perfect!! The rolled pizzelle was crispy yet tender inside. The staff was SO very helpful and patient. They were very busy but didn't make us feel rushed or like we were hindering them.

Daryl Nitz Edited 11 months ago

This is THE BEST bakery in this area. Prices are very fair. Worth the angst on The Strip District. Go early. They have some unique baked goods for sure. They are also incredibly KIND! NOTE biscotti from My Sweet Lilly, is superior to other biscotti you'll find in The Strip District. It can be dry and flavorless., BUT NOT at Lilly's!

Tami Lee 2 years ago

The aroma that greets you at the door when you enter is a pleasant savory smell! There are sweet treats all around the store! Everything looks so delicious! The staff were very friendly and eager to assist. Prices were a bit high for the lack in quality of the baked goods! The oreo cheesecake was delicious but sadly that is were it ends. The peanut butter cookie was hard and had to be microwaved when returning home. The pineapple upside cake was a soggy, sticky mess and the tiramisu was extremely too sweet. In the end, My Sweet Lilly was worth the try but nothing spectacular!